I just finished reading an article on one of my all-time favorite athletes, Walter Payton, and my overall feeling is sadness.
As a kid growing up in Chicago in the late ’70’s and ’80’s, before Michael Jordan ruled the city – there was Walter Payton. For many years, Payton played brilliantly on some pretty bad Chicago Bears teams. He would eventually win a Super Bowl with the Bears towards the end of his career. Not only was he was the best player on the team (by far), but he was arguably the best player of his era and one of the best of all-time.
He was smooth, but powerful. A showman, but humble. Payton played 13 seasons and only missed one game. He seemingly could do anything on the football field – run the ball, catch the ball and even pass the ball. And when his career was over, he held the record for the most rushing yards in NFL history.
“Sweetness”, as he was called, seemed to enjoy the game more than anyone else on the field. He always had a smile on his face and was known to be a practical joker. And at the same time, no one worked harder. His off-season workouts were legendary.
I loved watching Payton play football. And every kid I knew pretended to be him when playing football in the neighborhood. He was our favorite player. He was our hero.
Two days before my 29th birthday, Walter Payton died. Earlier that year a tearful Payton would announce he was suffering from rare liver disease called primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC). Reading the article in Sports Illustrated today (which was put together from excerpts from a controversial new book on Payton), brought back the sadness I felt the day he died.
The article made me sad for another reason. I was hoping it would be a nice trip down memory lane – remembering the man and player I loved watching so much as a kid. I was even thinking that my son Evan could read the article, because he knows how Payton was my favorite football player (Evan put my old Walter Payton poster up in the basement). Instead, the article largely detailed a side of Payton I never knew. A side, that seemingly, only a few knew. A not-so-positive side.
Payton apparently carried on an affair for many years. Abused pain medication. At times was distant from his kids. Dealt with depression and thoughts of suicide.
I’ve heard how many have denounced the article and book. The overall feeling is “what is their to gain” by trashing a man’s reputation, who doesn’t have the ability to defend it. I would agree with that. That does make me sad.
I’m also sad because he was a hero of mine. I’m sad thinking that his kids, who have already lost their father, now have to deal with the hurt that comes with these things being made public. I’m sad because we typically build people up, only to later look for ways to tear them down. I’m sad thinking of those who will be disillusioned by this book. I’m sad thinking of those who will be further jaded by this news, too.
Sadly, I am a bit disillusioned. I’m also a bit jaded. Part of me wants to say, “Should we really be surprised?” And really we shouldn’t. But not because he was just “another athlete” who seemed to be such a “good guy”, but wasn’t who we thought he was. The reality is you can change out “another athlete” with “another celebrity” or “another politician”. The reality is, you can change out “another athlete” with “another human being”. With me. With you.
I get sad because the Payton detailed in the article is how many will now view him. For many, that will be their last impression of him. While others will be in denial – either not believing the article or saying “what difference does it make?”
We do that. Hero or jerk. He has to be one or the other, right? We pick sides. We pick parts of people’s lives, either their biggest moments or most egregious sins and we define them. But we never know someone’s whole story. I don’t know all the amazing things Walter Payton may have done (or not done) for humanity. I don’t know if he ever felt regret or remorse. I don’t know if he ever sought forgiveness or tried to make amends. I don’t know if his life ended with refusal or redemption. That’s the danger when we try to define a life.
The truth of the matter is that we all have our “heroic” qualities and moments. We also all have those qualities and moments that we are not so proud of. The majority of us won’t have those parts of our life published and publicized for the world to hear (whether we are alive or dead).
For as much of a hero as he was on the football field, Walter Payton was all human. I won’t try to justify the “sins” of Walter Payton. Saying we’re human doesn’t give us a free pass to do whatever we want. But the reality is that being human, means being flawed. It means that despite our best efforts, we’ll mess up. We’ll disappoint. We’ll disillusion. Even those who appear to have it altogether.
My sins may very well be different from those of Walter Payton, but I’m a sinner none-the-less. When I’m dead, I’d hate for those sins to define me and define my “legacy”. Especially since they don’t tell my whole story.